kea/doc/devel/contribute.dox

// Copyright (C) 2013  Internet Systems Consortium, Inc. ("ISC")
//
// Permission to use, copy, modify, and/or distribute this software for any
// purpose with or without fee is hereby granted, provided that the above
// copyright notice and this permission notice appear in all copies.
//
// THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS" AND ISC DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES WITH
// REGARD TO THIS SOFTWARE INCLUDING ALL IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY
// AND FITNESS.  IN NO EVENT SHALL ISC BE LIABLE FOR ANY SPECIAL, DIRECT,
// INDIRECT, OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES OR ANY DAMAGES WHATSOEVER RESULTING FROM
// LOSS OF USE, DATA OR PROFITS, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, NEGLIGENCE
// OR OTHER TORTIOUS ACTION, ARISING OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE USE OR
// PERFORMANCE OF THIS SOFTWARE.

/**

 @page contributorGuide BIND10 Contributor's Guide

So you found a bug in BIND10 or plan to develop an extension and want to
send a patch? Great! This page will explain how to contribute your
changes and not get disappointed in the process.

@section contributorGuideWritePatch Writing a patch

Before you start working on a patch or a new feature, it is a good idea
to discuss it first with BIND10 developers. You can post your questions
to the \c bind10-dev mailing list
(https://lists.isc.org/mailman/listinfo/bind10-dev) for general BIND10
stuff, or to the \c bind10-dhcp mailing list
(https://lists.isc.org/mailman/listinfo/bind10-dhcp) for DHCP specific
topics. If you prefer to get faster feedback, most BIND10 developers
hang out in the \c bind10 jabber room
(xmpp:bind10@conference.jabber.isc.org). Those involved in DHCP also use
the \c dhcp chatroom (xmpp:dhcp@conference.jabber.isc.org). Feel free to
join these rooms and talk to us. It is possible that someone else is
working on your specific issue or perhaps the solution you plan to
implement is not the best one. Often having a 10 minute talk could save
many hours of engineering work.

First step would be to get the source code from our Git repository. The
procedure is very easy and is explained here:
http://bind10.isc.org/wiki/GitGuidelines.  While it is possible to
provide a patch against the latest stable release, it makes the review
process much easier if it is for latest code from the Git \c master
branch.

Ok, so you have written a patch? Great! Before you submit it, make sure
that your code compiles. This may seem obvious, but there's more to
it. You have surely checked that it compiles on your system, but BIND10
is portable software. Besides Linux, it is compiled and used on
relatively uncommon systems like OpenBSD and Solaris 11. Will your code
compile and work there? What about endianess? It is likely that you used
a regular x86 architecture machine to write your patch, but the software
is expected to run on many other architectures.

Does your patch conform to BIND10
<http://bind10.isc.org/wiki/CodingGuidelines>? You still can submit a
patch that does not adhere to it, but that will decrease its chances of
being accepted. If the deviations are minor, the BIND10 engineer who
does the review will likely fix the issues. However, if there are lots
of issues, the reviewer may simply reject the patch and ask you to fix
it before re-submitting.

@section contributorGuideUnittests Running unit-tests

One of the ground rules in BIND10 development is that every piece of
code has to be tested. We now have an extensive set of unit-tests for
almost every line of code. Even if you are fixing something small,
like a single line fix, it is encouraged to write unit-tests for that
change. That is even more true for new code. If you write a new
function, method or a class, you definitely should write unit-tests
for it.

BIND10 uses the Google C++ Testing Framework (also called googletest or
gtest) as a base for our C++ unit-tests. See
http://code.google.com/p/googletest/ for details. For Python unit-tests,
we use the its \c unittest library which is included in Python. You must
have \c gtest installed or at least extracted in a directory before
compiling BIND10 unit-tests. To enable unit-tests in BIND10, use:

@code
./configure --with-gtest=/path/to/your/gtest/dir
@endcode

or

@code
./configure --with-gtest-source=/path/to/your/gtest/dir
@endcode

There are other useful switches which can be passed to configure. It is always a good
idea to use \c --enable-logger-checks, which does sanity checks on logger
parameters. If you happen to modify anything in the documentation, use
\c --enable-generate-docs. If you are modifying DHCP code, you are likely
to be interested in enabling the MySQL backend for DHCP. Note that if the backend
is not enabled, MySQL specific unit-tests are skipped. From that
perspective, it is useful to use \c --with-dhcp-mysql. For a
complete list of all switches, use:

@code
 ./configure --help
@endcode

Depending on how you compiled or installed (e.g. from sources or using
some package management system) one of those two switches will find
gtest. After that you make run unit-tests:

@code
make check
@endcode

If you happen to add new files or modified Makefiles, it is also a
good idea to check if you haven't broken distribution process:

@code
make distcheck
@endcode

@section contributorGuideReview Going through a review

Once all those are checked and working, feel free to create a ticket
for your patch (http://bind10.isc.org) or attach your patch to the
existing ticket if there is one. You may drop a note to bind10 or dhcp
chatroom saying that you have submitted a patch. Alternatively, you
may send a note to bind10-dev or bind10-dhcp lists.

Here's the tricky part. One of BIND10 developers will review your
patch, but it may not happen immediately. Unfortunately, developers
are usually working under tight schedule, so any extra unplanned
review work sometimes make take a while. Having said that, we value
external contributions very much and will do whatever we can to
review patches in a timely manner. Don't get discouraged if your
patch is not accepted after first review. To keep the code quality
high, we use the same review processes for internal code and for
external patches. It may take several cycles of review/updated patch
submissions before the code is finally accepted.

Once the process is almost completed, the developer will likely ask
you how you would like to be credited. The typical answers are by
first,last name, by nickname, by company or anonymously. Typically we
will add a note to ChangeLog. If the contributted feature is big or
critical for whatever reason, it may be also mentioned in release
notes.

@section contributorGuideExtra Extra steps

If you are interested in even more in-depth testing, you are welcome
to visit BIND10 build farm: http://git.bind10.isc.org/~tester/builder/builder-new.html
This is a life result page with all tests being run on various systems.
Besides basic unit-tests, we also run them with valgrind (memory debugger),
with cppcheck and scan-build (static code analyzers), Lettuce system tests
and more. Although it is not possible for non ISC employees to run tests
on that farm, it is possible that your contributed patch will end up there
sooner or later.

*/